Students Are Confused About AI and It's Our Fault (with Dr. Bette Ludwig)
Dr. Bette Ludwig spent 20 years in higher ed working directly with students before leaving to build something different — a Substack (AI Can Do That), a consulting practice, and most recently, the Socratic AI Method, an AI literacy program that teaches students how to think critically alongside AI while keeping their own voice intact.
That last part is the hard part.
Craig opens with the question that drives the whole episode: Socratic dialogue requires you to already know enough to ask good questions. So what happens when a student doesn’t know enough to push back on what AI is telling them? Bette’s answer is both practical and unsettling — younger students literally don’t know what they don’t know, and that gap is where the real danger lives.
The conversation moves into dependency territory when Craig shares a moment from his own morning: Claude froze while he was editing a manuscript, and he felt a flash of genuine panic. Two seconds later, he remembered he could just… write. But he names the uncomfortable truth — his students won’t have that fallback. Bette compares it to the panic we feel when the wifi drops, which is both funny and a little alarming when you sit with it.
From there, the three dig into the policy mess — teachers across the hall from each other running opposite AI rules, students confused about what’s allowed, and educational systems moving at what Bette calls “a glacial pace” while the technology sprints ahead. Craig shares his own college’s approach: you have to have a policy, it has to be clear, but how restrictive or permissive it is remains your call. The non-negotiable? You can’t leave students in the dark.
The episode’s most surprising thread might be Bette’s observations about how students actually use AI. It’s not just homework. They’re using it for companionship, personal problems, cooking questions, building apps — ways that don’t even register as “AI use” to most faculty. Her closing point lands hard: students have never used technology the way adults assume they should, and they’re going to do the same thing with AI.
Key Takeaways
1. The Socratic method has an AI prerequisite problem. You need existing knowledge to know what questions to ask, which means younger students are especially vulnerable to accepting AI output uncritically. Bette and Craig agree that junior/senior year of high school is roughly where the cognitive capacity for meaningful pushback begins.
2. AI dependency is already happening to experienced users. Craig describes a two-second panic when Claude froze mid-editorial. He recovered by remembering he could just write the way he always has. His concern: students who grew up with AI won’t have that muscle memory to fall back on.
3. The “helpful by default” design is a subtle problem. Craig raises the point that AI systems are programmed to be agreeable, which means they can lock students into a single mode of thinking without anyone noticing. The hallucinations get all the attention, but the quiet steering might be worse.
4. Policy chaos is the norm, not the exception. Teachers in the same hallway can have opposite AI rules. Bette recommends clarity above all: whatever your policy is, make it explicit. In K–12, she argues for uniform policies. In higher ed, where faculty governance complicates things, Craig’s approach works — require a policy, let faculty own the specifics.
5. Grace matters more than enforcement right now. Both Craig and Bette push back on the “AI cop” mentality. Students sometimes cross lines they didn’t know existed, just like past generations plagiarized without understanding citation rules. Teaching moments beat punitive responses, especially when the rules themselves are still being written.
6. Students use AI in ways faculty don’t expect. Companionship, personal problems, everyday questions, building apps. Bette’s observation: students are as likely to use AI for roommate conflicts as for essay writing. Faculty who don’t use AI themselves can’t begin to understand these patterns.
7. Education isn’t moving fast enough. New York got an AI bachelor’s program launched in fall 2025, which Bette calls “Mach speed for higher ed.” Most institutions are still in the resistance-or-denial phase. The shared worry: AI across the curriculum could become another empty checkbox, like ethics across the curriculum before it.
Links
Dr. Ludwig's website: https://www.betteludwig.com/
AI Can Do That Substack: https://betteconnects.substack.com/
AI Goes to College: https://www.aigoestocollege.com/
Craig's AI Goes to College Substack: https://aigoestocollege.substack.com/
Mentioned in this episode:
AI Goes to College Newsletter
Welcome to another episode of AI Goes to College, the podcast that helps higher ed professionals figure out what in the world is going on with generative AI.
Speaker AAnd as always, I am joined by my friend, colleague and co host, Dr. Robert E. Crossler of Washington State University.
Speaker AAnd today we are joined by a special guest, Dr. Bette Ludwig.
Speaker AShe's been in higher ed, or was in higher ed for over 20 years, serving in a variety of student facing positions.
Speaker AIn 2022, she left higher ed to strike out on her own as a writer and consultant focused on helping students and parents make smarter academic and career choices, which is something we all need.
Speaker ASince leaving higher ed behind, she's written over 450 articles.
Speaker ARob, have you written over 450 articles?
Speaker AI haven't.
Speaker BI've thought up 450 articles.
Speaker BI haven't written them.
Speaker AThat's right.
Speaker AAnd these articles are on education, leadership, strategic thinking, and of course, AI.
Speaker ABET and I connected through her fantastic substack AI can do that, which helps educators, parents and otherwise busy people stay informed about the rapid developments in AI and what they mean for education.
Speaker AI was really intrigued by her latest effort, the Socratic AI Method, which is a comprehensive AI literacy program that helps students learn how to think critically with AI while maintaining their own voice.
Speaker ABet likes to combine her academic training with hands on expertise to bridge the gap between rapidly emerging technology and the needs of students and families.
Speaker AShe holds a Ph.D. in educational leadership from Western Michigan University and an Ms.
Speaker AIn counseling from Westchester University and a BA in psychology from Michigan State.
Speaker AAnd we'll put a link to BET's homepage, bet Ludwig.com in the show notes.
Speaker AThat's where you want to go for all things bet.
Speaker ABeth, welcome.
Speaker ADid I get all of that right?
Speaker AIt was a lot.
Speaker CYou got all of that right.
Speaker AI'm kind of out of breath.
Speaker AKind of out of breath.
Speaker ALet's start off with something that Rob and I have been wrestling with.
Speaker AAnd that's the difference between offloading thinking to AI, outsourcing it, and what we like to call genuine CO thinking.
Speaker AWe call it co produced cognition.
Speaker AYour Socratic AI method seemed to land squarely on that CO thinking end of things.
Speaker ABut here's what I struggle with.
Speaker ASo Socratic dialogue requires a certain level of existing knowledge to even know what questions to ask.
Speaker AHow does this work with a student who doesn't know enough about what to push back on when they're engaging with AI?
Speaker CThat's a good question.
Speaker CAnd you're absolutely right.
Speaker CAnd that's where it gets tougher for Students.
Speaker CAnd I think that's where teaching them how to use this and how to push back and how not to get too dependent on using it for your writing.
Speaker CFor it's okay to think through things with it.
Speaker CI use it a lot for that brainstorming.
Speaker CThat's one of the things that I really push with the students is that you cannot become completely reliant on this and depend on it for everything.
Speaker CIf you want to brainstorm with it, if you want to use it to help you study for tests, if you want to use it to critique your writing.
Speaker CBut you can't let it do everything for you because it does get easy to fall into that.
Speaker COne of the things that I really focus on is explaining to them it hallucinates.
Speaker CYou can't trust the output like it's factual.
Speaker CYou have to go back and check everything that it gives you because it will give you things very confidently.
Speaker CThat is not accurate.
Speaker CSo one of the things that we have to really instill in them is that you have to double check it.
Speaker CIf you're just having a back and forth conversation about things and reflecting on your thoughts, that's a little different.
Speaker CBut if you're getting things that it's saying this actually happened, you can't just accept that.
Speaker CLike, I wrote an article on the Pope recently speaking out about AI and I threw it in Gemini.
Speaker CAnd Gemini says Pope Leo doesn't exist.
Speaker CI'm like, pretty sure he does.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker APeople in Chicago would object to that.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CEven ChatGPT said it's not Pope Leo, it's Pope Francis now.
Speaker CThat was the previous Pope.
Speaker CThey both knew that it was 2026 though.
Speaker CSo it's those types of things that you have to push back on it.
Speaker CAnd we're going to really, really have to teach students how to do that as we start integrating AI in.
Speaker BBut that's a great point that you made.
Speaker BAnd I'm thinking back on the last guest we interviewed.
Speaker BWe were talking about the age at which engaging with students in AI and beginning to establish this and think about this and what is that?
Speaker BAnd he kind of landed about juniors in high schools where they have the cognitive abilities to be able to engage in these conversations.
Speaker BWhat are you seeing as far as what that point is?
Speaker BBecause I know that middle schoolers are even using this.
Speaker BAt what point do young people have the ability to engage in this sort of a Socratic dialogue and questioning what they're getting from the machine?
Speaker CYeah, I think your last guest was pretty spot on with that.
Speaker CI think really junior, senior Year is when you really start seeing that.
Speaker CBut I do think that we have to start teaching them about it earlier than that, at least in an introductory type way.
Speaker CBut yeah, they're not going to be able to push back on some of this because you think back to when you were in high school or junior high, you don't know what you don't even know.
Speaker CAnd so we have an advantage, right, because we have life experience and we can look at it and say, no, that's not right, you're wrong.
Speaker CI was watching a YouTube video yesterday with Daniel Pink and he had put all these prompts in and was getting all of this very personal stuff back because he had asked these prompts and he kept pushing back and saying, no, that's not right.
Speaker COh, that's not right.
Speaker CBut he knows himself enough to be able to say that.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSomebody younger doesn't.
Speaker CWhich goes back to something I've been saying too, that I really think we need to think about restructuring education, focusing on teaching skills, empathy, self awareness, emotional regulation, teaching those things even earlier and focusing on being aware of what they're thinking, what they're feeling.
Speaker CBecause if you're not aware of those things, how can you push back on anything?
Speaker AYeah, I worry about students being reluctant to push back on AI.
Speaker AThey often won't challenge your instructors.
Speaker AThey won't challenge anybody they see as an authority figure.
Speaker AAnd if they view AI as an authority figure, they may not push back enough.
Speaker AAnd the hallucinations are a problem, without a doubt.
Speaker ABut I think there's a more subtle problem in that AI can lock into a certain mode of thinking and there's just one.
Speaker AAnd it's going to think that way and it's going to try to guide your thinking that way.
Speaker AAnd that's just not the way the world is.
Speaker AAnd it's not the way to develop your critical thinking skills.
Speaker ASo I worry about that as well.
Speaker CYeah, I think that's a good worry to have.
Speaker CYou're right.
Speaker CBecause it does get into that kind of mode of thinking and you have to really push back hard on it.
Speaker CAnd there is some of that.
Speaker CThat's programming.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CThey can program this not to be that way.
Speaker CThese companies aren't deciding how they're.
Speaker CThey're programming these things.
Speaker AAnthropic released the Claude Constitution, which is, I don't know, 75 or 80 pages long.
Speaker AAnd I've only started going through it, but one of its kind of prime directives is to be helpful.
Speaker AAnd I think that leads to some problems.
Speaker AYou can override that through prompting.
Speaker ABut you've got to know that that's even a problem before you try to solve that problem.
Speaker ABut it can be such a fantastic co thinker.
Speaker AI was working on an editorial for a special volume of a book series on AI and HR management, and it was helping me brainstorm research questions.
Speaker ABut we went back and forth, so it came up with some.
Speaker AAnd I said, you know, these are really generic.
Speaker AThey're not really tied to what's in the volume, and they're kind of obvious, and let's dig in.
Speaker AAnd we went back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and ended up with something that I probably would not have come up with on my own, but that AI certainly would not have come up with on their own.
Speaker AAnd I think that's probably a little advanced for a lot of students.
Speaker AYes, but that ought to be our goal.
Speaker AHow do you produce something that's better?
Speaker ASo.
Speaker AYeah, but you know how we get there.
Speaker BSo, Craig, I think this makes me think of something that Bet wrote in this Thinking with AI about outsourcing your memory to AI and how that initial relief turns into something that can actually be more like a cage.
Speaker BSo that metaphor really sticks with me, because I think it's something that happens with our students, that they'll get something from AI where AI does the thinking for them in that first thing, and it feels like a freedom to them, where they're like, aha, I've got it.
Speaker BThis is brilliant.
Speaker BBecause that initial.
Speaker BI want to answer this question.
Speaker BI want to please you.
Speaker BAnd ultimately, it traps their thinking to where they don't move from where that initial anchor is.
Speaker BDo you see this pattern with students, or am I imagining things?
Speaker CNo, there's definitely that pattern there because they want to get stuff done.
Speaker CLet's just let me get this assignment done, or let me.
Speaker CWhatever's going on, let me get this accomplished.
Speaker CThat goes back to the pushing back, right?
Speaker CNot pushing back on it because not knowing what they don't know.
Speaker CSo, yes.
Speaker CAnd also becoming dependent on it, which is easy to do, and.
Speaker CAnd when it's right there and you can do something in 10 minutes versus spending an hour wrestling with it, it is tough to push back on it.
Speaker AFirst of all, I feel compelled to throw in Janis Joplin and Kris Kristofferson.
Speaker AFreedom is just another word for nothing left to lose.
Speaker AAnd that's got some real cognitive consequences when we think about AI and outsourcing everything to AI.
Speaker ABut I want to relate an experience that I had this morning so I was working on this editorial, and Claude froze, having technical difficulties, and I had this moment of panic.
Speaker AI did.
Speaker AI had this really weird moment of panic because I'm so close.
Speaker AI'm on the next to the last subsection in this whole editorial.
Speaker AAnd it's like, oh, my God, what do I do now?
Speaker AAnd it's like, oh, well, you could just do what you've always done.
Speaker AAnd the way I was working with Claude is I would write something, and then I actually have a keyboard shortcut for how is this?
Speaker AAnd how is this.
Speaker AI'd paste in what I had, and it would say, well, this transition is a little abrupt, and this could tie back to something in one of the chapters in the volume.
Speaker AIt's like, okay, I could have just not done that, and it would have been fine.
Speaker ABut it was this weird, visceral panic for about two seconds.
Speaker AAnd that kind of worried me.
Speaker AI've been at this a really long time.
Speaker AAnd so I quickly pivoted to, oh, well, I'll just write the way I've always written.
Speaker ABut students aren't going to have that capability.
Speaker AThey're going to be frozen, I'm afraid.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker CI think that ultimately we're going to have to completely reteach how we teach a lot of things, like.
Speaker COr restructure the whole foundation of it.
Speaker CAnd I could envision a future where that instead of creating it from scratch by yourself, you're in class actually working on developmentally editing a lot of things with AI rather than coming up with it by yourself.
Speaker AI always get very concerned when we're talking with somebody and there's a long pause and a sigh.
Speaker AIt's like, either that was a really great, great question, or bet's trying to figure out how to not say, you know, you're just an idiot.
Speaker BOr both.
Speaker AOr both.
Speaker AIt could be both.
Speaker AIt could be both.
Speaker ASo, yeah, it's the kind of thing that we're going to have to struggle with because you don't want to cut it off.
Speaker ABecause, look, this editorial is going to be better because I had Claude working with me.
Speaker AIt just is.
Speaker AIt's going to be better.
Speaker ASo you don't want to not use that.
Speaker ABut at the same time, it's like, wow, you should not have even felt that little moment of panic, no matter how quickly you recovered from it.
Speaker ASo it's a weird time.
Speaker CIt is a weird time.
Speaker CBut is that much different than the panic that you feel when your wifi goes out or when you can't find your cell phone or you've got no cell phone coverage.
Speaker CYou know what I mean?
Speaker CI think right now the panic is because this is kind of newer, but I know I feel a whole lot of panic when my wifi goes out and I've had it where it's been out a couple of days and I'm like, oh, this is almost as bad as having no electricity.
Speaker CAnd that's kind of ridiculous to think, right?
Speaker ABut you're talking to somebody that has fiber optic starlink and a second starlink, plus the ability to hotspot to the phone.
Speaker ASo, yeah.
Speaker BSo all of this, Craig has made me.
Speaker BI've got like seven questions in my head.
Speaker BI'm going to try to boil it down to two of these ideas into one question.
Speaker BAnd whenever I hear about we need to rethink and redo how we do education.
Speaker BWe have such inertia in the way that the question is, how do we do that?
Speaker BAnd then the second part of that question is, I've recently read about Gen Z and their test scores showing that they actually didn't perform as well as the generation before them.
Speaker BWith the blame on ed tech, on social media, on the amount of screen time that students are having.
Speaker BIn this world of AI, I see quicker answers, maybe giving more time for screen time.
Speaker BAnd we're supposed to be changing how we do education, but technology may actually be getting in the way of true learning.
Speaker BWhat does five years from now look like?
Speaker BAnd how do we even get there, given the systematic inertia that's in place?
Speaker CWell, that's the hard part, right?
Speaker CAnd you've got all these different things going on in the US You've got the federal government, then you've got the state agencies, and every state has regulations that they have that schools and universities have to meet.
Speaker CAnd if you don't live in a state where you have a state government that is willing to work with you, look how fast New York got an AI program through for bachelor's degrees.
Speaker CThey actually started them in 2025 in the fall.
Speaker CThat is really mach speed for higher ed.
Speaker CThey don't get programs pushed through that quickly.
Speaker CAnd so there has to be a lot of coordination.
Speaker CAnd right now we're still at that weird phase where you've got a bunch of people not wanting AI, not wanting to work with it, not wanting to experiment with it, thinking it's just going to, I don't know, hopefully go away until we get to the place where the majority of people are moving forward with this.
Speaker CIt's going to be hard, I think, to move the educational system and five years, you know, that's when some of them are planning on having graduation requirements for AI stuff in place.
Speaker C20, 29 educational systems unfortunately move at a glacial pace.
Speaker AYes, they do.
Speaker AWe have a program that's slowly working its way through, and Louisiana is actually fairly quick.
Speaker ABut I really worry that it's gonna be another something across the curriculum.
Speaker ASo in business schools, it was ethics across the curriculum, and then it was globalization across the curriculum and technology across the curriculum.
Speaker AAnd that can work.
Speaker AThere's nothing wrong with that as a basic idea, but I'm not speaking about any schools with which I am currently or have been affiliated in the past, but in my experience, going around to accreditations meetings and that kind of thing, it's often this veneer.
Speaker AWe've got this.
Speaker AYeah, there's a lecture in this class and a lecture in this class and a lecture in this class.
Speaker ANone of it's coordinated, none of it's cohesive.
Speaker ANone of it builds towards anything significant.
Speaker AAnd I feel that happening with AI, and I think that's going to be a huge problem.
Speaker AAnd I think business schools are better about this than a lot of other.
Speaker CYes, I would agree with you, because they have the outside business world knocking at their door, keeping them a little bit more on task.
Speaker CThat is a problem.
Speaker CAnd I'm personally not sure putting AI in every classroom, every subject, is the answer here, at least not initially.
Speaker CI think the way to scale this is to start having more individual classes and making those required and getting students broader knowledge of it, rather than saying, okay, you have to incorporate this into every subject matter across the board.
Speaker CI don't see.
Speaker CSee how that.
Speaker CFirst of all, they don't.
Speaker CIf you're looking at K through 12, they don't have time.
Speaker CThey're already, like, packed all the way with what they have to do.
Speaker CPlus the state mandates, the testing mandates, everything else that's going on.
Speaker CAnd then in higher education, you have the same thing.
Speaker CAnd then think about when you have a couple of snow days, which we actually had here in Michigan because of the weather being so bad, then you've got instructors packing even more in those days that they miss.
Speaker CNow they've got to incorporate all these other things.
Speaker CI just, I. I don't know how y' all are gonna do it.
Speaker BWell, and I think that's the challenge, too, is there are places where you truly need to learn knowledge.
Speaker BBut how do you do it in an AI resilient way?
Speaker BAnd what does that look like?
Speaker BK through 12?
Speaker BHow do you ensure that the students are, are learning what they need to and not just going home and punching it into the machine and then getting the answers.
Speaker BIt's paradigm changing and how you have to approach education.
Speaker BAnd there's.
Speaker BNobody's told us the rules for how to do that.
Speaker BSo it's like we have all these different experiments going on where we're trying what seems right to us.
Speaker BAnd yeah, some people, I think are going to do it better than others.
Speaker BAnd then how does that get disseminated?
Speaker BSo we learn those best practices and we do so in a way to where we aren't harming a generation of youth who are developing in the midst of this rapidly changing environment.
Speaker BIt's a big scary problem.
Speaker BI think that we need to be.
Speaker ATalking about more and it's at a scale and fundamentally more at the core of what we do than anything else I've seen in a very long time in higher ed.
Speaker AThe Internet came along and that kind of changed modalities and it kind of changed a little bit about how students went about finding information.
Speaker ABut compared to this, that was nothing.
Speaker AAnd I think it's a fundamental shift.
Speaker AAnd we're not saying what hasn't already been said by a lot of other people, but I think one of our messages is you need to do something.
Speaker AEven if you're an individual faculty member.
Speaker AIf nothing else, you better learn what this stuff is all about.
Speaker CI don't understand how people can't be experimenting.
Speaker CHow are you not experimenting with this?
Speaker CAnd I still have people that will say things like, like somebody said something about AI is it's not funny.
Speaker CI'm like, have you used it?
Speaker CIt can be incredibly funny.
Speaker CThere's a lot of back and forth experience I've had with it where it's really hilarious and I'll start laughing at some of the stuff that it comes up with.
Speaker CSo I just, I think that people early on decided that either this is no good or I've just decided we shouldn't be using it.
Speaker CAnd I feel like that's not the solution here because the kids are using it.
Speaker CAnd if we don't understand how it works, how are we going to even be able to talk to them about it and explain anything to them?
Speaker CAnd I think one of the biggest things that we have to be open to is being open with them and talking about some of.
Speaker CWe don't know that.
Speaker CWe don't know everything that's going on with us either.
Speaker CTeachers don't have all of the answers, parents don't have all of the answers.
Speaker CWe're all learning this as we go.
Speaker CAnd it is scary.
Speaker CIt is scary because we can see how it can potentially really hamper learning and hinder it.
Speaker CThey can't, no.
Speaker CAnd we also don't even know what is it that is that constitutes the basics anymore.
Speaker BWell, what I think is an interesting challenge in all of this is in some ways, the further you go down in the hierarchy of who's in charge, whether it's the K through 12 or in higher education, is at some level they're looking above to say, what's our policy, what's our rules, what are we supposed to be doing?
Speaker BAnd when that's ill defined, it moves that policy establishment to lower level, say the faculty.
Speaker BAnd so now there's not this one size fits all policy for how everybody's supposed to do things.
Speaker BAnd what I hear from students is they get confused because the rules differ as they move from place to place to place.
Speaker BAre you seeing that to where?
Speaker BDepending on who you talk to, the policies are different.
Speaker BAnd how do you see that being coped with?
Speaker CYeah, absolutely.
Speaker CThat is a problem.
Speaker CI mean, you can have a teacher literally across the hall banning it, saying, nope, can't use it in my classroom, and somebody else experimenting with it.
Speaker CAnd students are confused, parents are confused, and even the policies can be really vague.
Speaker CI actually created a GPT system.
Speaker CStudents could actually put the policies in it and get hopefully some more explicit language on what exactly is allowed and what isn't.
Speaker CBut I always stress you have to ask if you are confused.
Speaker CThis is not a ask for forgiveness later kind of thing because some people are very rigid about how they view using this.
Speaker CAnd if they say it can't be used and you use it and it can be a problem.
Speaker CBut yes, it's very confusing and they want to use it.
Speaker CThink about you're being told, well, you can't use it for this.
Speaker CThey're seeing it as well, why this is helping me.
Speaker CThis is a way that I can learn and use it and you want me to go back and do things the old fashioned way.
Speaker CAnd it's not something that is helpful.
Speaker BWhat I hear you saying is that you've empowered students to be able to learn how to interpret things, but at the same time it's a problem that is being caused by thus far, the inability for the teachers in the room to come to an agreement.
Speaker BIf you could give a piece of advice to whether it's a high school or a university or even a higher level of oversight, that would be helpful.
Speaker BIn the midst of training people up.
Speaker BWhat would that one piece of advice be?
Speaker CWell, the one piece of advice that I would have is whatever the policy is that you create, it needs to be very clear.
Speaker CIt can't be ambiguous.
Speaker CThere's a lot of ambiguity with how they define what's allowed and what isn't.
Speaker CAnd you can't have this thing that is so hard to understand that they don't even know what they can and cannot do.
Speaker CIt has to be explicit.
Speaker CFor one, for two.
Speaker CI don't think that you really should be having all these different policies in K12 with the teacher deciding there needs to be a more uniform policy that gets a little trickier in higher ed because faculty have governance and they cannot be told how to teach their classes.
Speaker CSo that gets a lot stickier when you get into higher ed.
Speaker CBut again, what I would argue with is that they need to have very clear policies within their class.
Speaker CNow, if you can get all faculty to do that.
Speaker AI'm still a big fan of what we've done here in the college.
Speaker AWe have a policy that basically says you have to have a policy.
Speaker AAnd it's, I don't know, five or six areas that you have to address.
Speaker AAnd we give a range.
Speaker AYou can be maximally restrictive, you can be maximally permissive.
Speaker AThat's entirely up to you.
Speaker ABut what you cannot do is leave students in the dark.
Speaker CThat's good.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd it's worked out pretty well.
Speaker AWe had no pushback on it that I've heard of.
Speaker AAnd it accounts for faculty governance and faculty academic freedom.
Speaker ABut at the same time, it's at least fair to the students.
Speaker AThe other.
Speaker AI'd like to hear your take on this because it may differ from high school to college, but I think you also have to give a little grace to students.
Speaker ACause somebody kind of is a little bit over that line.
Speaker AThat's a teaching moment.
Speaker AHere's why that's a bad thing for you to have done.
Speaker ANot just because of class rules, but because you need to know this stuff.
Speaker AAnd what you've done is just hurt your learning as opposed to the hammer of God coming down and crushing their grade.
Speaker AI think because it's so gray right now, it's time to be a little slack.
Speaker ASlack's not.
Speaker ASorry, can I correct that?
Speaker AIt's time to be a little understanding.
Speaker ASlack is not the right word.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CUnderstanding is good.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd sometimes they legitimately aren't trying to do anything wrong.
Speaker CIt just, you know, they don't know.
Speaker CI used to have students when I taught classes in college, they plagiarized.
Speaker CThey didn't do it on purpose.
Speaker CThey literally didn't know that you were supposed to cite certain things.
Speaker CSo I think that, yes, we have to have a little bit of grace with this.
Speaker CAnd teaching moments are good.
Speaker CWe don't have to scare the bejeebis out of them.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd I don't want to be an AI cop either.
Speaker AThat's part of it.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd you can't.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CHow can you?
Speaker CI mean, yes, when you read things, you can probably kind of speculate.
Speaker CThat's probably AI, but.
Speaker CBut you can't know for sure because none of the AI detectors are accurate.
Speaker CNone of them.
Speaker CIf you put your thing in four different ones, you're going to get maybe one that it trips, the other three it doesn't, or a couple that it does, the others that it doesn't.
Speaker CSo you can't trust any of that.
Speaker CSo how do you go to a student and say you're using AI?
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd you're only going to catch the lazy ones that don't know what they're doing?
Speaker AIf they're willing to put a little bit of effort into it, you're never going to know.
Speaker CSo have you heard of the instructors putting injections in there?
Speaker AYeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker CI'm just like, so what's the goal of that?
Speaker CIf you're explicit about it, I guess then I'm okay with that.
Speaker CIf you specifically say there's things in here, blah, blah, blah.
Speaker CBut then they can get around that by doing something else.
Speaker AI tell my students, look, if you cheat on this, I might catch you.
Speaker AI might not.
Speaker ABut you're just not going to know the stuff you need to know.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AAnd I'll get you at some point.
Speaker AMight not be on this assignment, but, you know, this is designed to help you learn the stuff that you're going to need to be able to pass the test.
Speaker AAnd so I'll find out, and I'm okay with that.
Speaker BWell, I think what you're getting at, Craig, is at some level, the stakes of where the points are earned becomes different.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BIf it's truly an activity that I need you to learn these things so you can demonstrate it later on, it may be that it's in that later on that the stakes exist, whether it's the test where they're in a controlled environment where they can demonstrate their learning, or whether it's in a presentation where they get up in front of an audience and demonstrate their ability to articulate what it is that they've learned.
Speaker BAs I've seen education, as I've gone up through it and then into higher education, there's a lot of small stakes that go on where you can earn a good portion of your points by doing the little things that you might be able to AI your way through and never truly demonstrate.
Speaker BDemonstrate learning.
Speaker BSo I think that's part of the conversation too is they don't want to discourage people by you get one final exam and it's a make or break thing of whether or not you pass this class.
Speaker BBut at the same time, where are those key moments of demonstrating whether it's knowledge or whether it's the ability to engage in a process or whatever that is?
Speaker BI think it begins looking a little different than take home worksheets that you complete in an opportunity to demonstrate skills.
Speaker AAt the risk of being the old man who shakes his fist and tells kids to get off his lawn.
Speaker AHaving a midterm and a final worked for a really long time.
Speaker AI know that's not the fashion these days, but I don't know, maybe we should go back to that.
Speaker ASorry, bet I interrupted you.
Speaker CYeah, I was gonna say there are still a lot of classes that kind of teach that way.
Speaker CWhen I left the last university I was at, there were plenty of them that did midterm and final, especially in the health and human services field, the biology classes, things like that also too.
Speaker CA lot of the big classes that have 200, 300 students in, that's how they're doing it.
Speaker CThey're testing with multiple choice exams, maybe some fill in the blank kind of things, but they're not doing take home essays and things like that.
Speaker CSo I don't know the class sizes with the classes that you have.
Speaker CBut a lot of these problems aren't really going to affect some of these instructors.
Speaker CProbably a huge chunk of instructors really if you think about it, especially at these big ten universities, large universities, they don't have to change anything.
Speaker CIn these intro classes that have a couple hundred students, they continue and do what they're doing.
Speaker CThey don't care if students use AI to help them study for their tests or not.
Speaker CThey're in class as long as they don't have the meta glasses on.
Speaker CI suppose you do have to maybe monitor a little bit more in terms of making sure they're not using other things.
Speaker CBut I think that for a chunk of people this isn't going to impact them at all.
Speaker CIt's certain classes that it's going to get really sticky.
Speaker CThe smaller ones, the writing classes, graduate classes, you would hope that grad students aren't doing these things, but I'd be willing to bet that they probably are.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AYep.
Speaker AThese are big questions.
Speaker ABig questions.
Speaker ASo as we get ready to wrap up, I want to ask the really big question.
Speaker AYou're in a unique position because you see students before we get them.
Speaker AEspecially with your background in student services, you also had that experience from a different perspective.
Speaker ASo what do you think would surprise most college faculty about how high school students are either currently using or are currently thinking about AI?
Speaker CI think they'd probably be surprised at how much they're using it and for the types of things that they use it for.
Speaker CThey aren't just using it for educational purposes.
Speaker CThere are a lot of them that uses it for just regular, everyday tasks like how do I cook this pizza kind of thing, stuff that you would normally Google or not do at all and just kind of trial and error it.
Speaker CSo they're using it for a lot of everyday things.
Speaker CThey're using it a lot for companionship, personal problems.
Speaker CI think that surprises a lot of people, parents especially.
Speaker CThey don't think their kids are using it this way.
Speaker CThe data says otherwise.
Speaker CThey're using it in ways that isn't just about learning, but they also use it in ways that enhance their learning.
Speaker CThey want to do better on their tests, they want to do better, and they see this as a tool to do it.
Speaker CBuilding apps, building things that we don't think of doing because it's not something we're interested in, but they are.
Speaker BAnd I would argue that what you describe right there is that world of continuous learning, of learning in the midst of life.
Speaker BWe realize students are doing those sorts of things that they're using these tools, whether it's getting counseling with a problem they're struggling with at 11 o' clock at night or whatever when, you know, people aren't answering phones.
Speaker BWhat are some ways you think that education can lean into the students who are, I would call, are they native AI users, but you know, kind of younger AI users that they haven't learned it while they're in college, but they're coming into college.
Speaker BAre there things that we can leverage in our thinking that can help meet them where they're at in some ways that would create some nice synergies and leading to their success?
Speaker CYeah, well, I think the one thing that we need to do is use it, because how can you understand what that experience might even be like if you're not using it?
Speaker CI use it as Google a lot.
Speaker CI don't even Google stuff anymore.
Speaker CSo I understand that desire to do that because that's one of the ways that I use it.
Speaker CI also use it for very mundane things to ask IT questions.
Speaker CI also ask IT questions to help me deal with personal issues, so I understand those needs.
Speaker CBut if you're not using it in that way and some students comes to you and says, I use it to talk about my personal problems or help me deal with roommate issues or whatever, then you're not going to even be able to understand what they might even be doing.
Speaker CBut I do think colleges and universities could use it for those types of things.
Speaker CWhat's one of the biggest things that a lot of students struggle with living on campus?
Speaker CRoommate problems.
Speaker CRoommate conflicts.
Speaker CYou can use that in housing situations to help them kind of work through maybe some of these conflicts that they might have.
Speaker CYou can use it in career development to help them interview.
Speaker CPut an interview into the ChatGPT, have it ask the questions, then have it critique your answers.
Speaker CHave.
Speaker CHave rehearsals with it.
Speaker CYou can use it in advising for students who.
Speaker CWho may think they know exactly what they want to do, but maybe don't understand what it takes to actually get there.
Speaker CAnd so they can use it for that.
Speaker CThere's so many ways that you can actually use this educationally and outside of that, but I think they need to be taught it.
Speaker CI remember several years ago when I was working in a grant program, we worked with some of the students, and one of the big surprises that they found was students didn't use the Internet the way that we thought that they should use it.
Speaker CSo, like, instead of looking up how to cite something, they would just try and find a place where they could just dump the stuff in and it would cite it for them rather than figuring out how to do it themselves.
Speaker CAnd we're like, well, why don't they just Google how to actually do this?
Speaker CAnd students would email me all the time about questions.
Speaker CThat is, did you go to the website?
Speaker CIt's really right on there.
Speaker CAnd I would usually send them back the link specifically where it was.
Speaker CInstead of taking 10 minutes to search on the Internet to find it, they would email me and then have to wait like a day to get the answer so they don't use it in the way that we think that they should.
Speaker CAnd guess what?
Speaker CThey're going to do the same thing with AI.
Speaker AYeah, absolutely.
Speaker AAbsolutely.
Speaker AWell, this has been a great conversation.
Speaker AI want to give you a chance to tell our listeners anything you want them to know about what you offer.
Speaker AI know You've got a number of books on leadership and you've got your program.
Speaker ASo tell them all about it.
Speaker CYeah, so I started off writing about leadership.
Speaker CThat's what my background is in educational leadership.
Speaker CAnd then as I was coming into reading more about AI and I started using it myself.
Speaker CI come from this.
Speaker CNot from a technology background, but from an educational background, one where I worked with students, one where I use this technology myself.
Speaker CSo I have a very unique perspective on it in the sense that I am not a techie, but I've learned how to use these things myself and how they fit into my life.
Speaker CAnd I think ways that students can learn how to use these tools without feeling overwhelmed and helping parents work through these things as well.
Speaker CBecause we are deep in the weeds of this, right?
Speaker CThey aren't.
Speaker CThey're going to work.
Speaker CThey're doing what they need to do to take care of their families.
Speaker CThey're taxiing their kids around to extracurricular activities.
Speaker CThey're not thinking through this stuff every day, all day, like.
Speaker CLike we are.
Speaker CAnd so that's what I help people with, is to help them use this in a way that can enhance what you're doing without students getting in trouble doing it.
Speaker AAnd I really like the way that your articles start from your experiences.
Speaker AHey, I was doing this thing with ChatGPT, and then you generalize it up and make it something that's useful for just about anybody.
Speaker ASo that's great with your articles, Rob.
Speaker AAnything else?
Speaker BNo, I just want to thank BET for taking the time to hang out with us.
Speaker BPart of me, when I wake up in the morning and I know we have an interview like this, I'm like, man, it's going to be too short because we could talk about so much and it could be such a, you know, a great day filled with.
Speaker BWith these sorts of conversations.
Speaker BSo I do greatly appreciate you taking the time.
Speaker BIt's 8:45am My time, so this, for me is a great way to start my day.
Speaker BAnd I'm pretty sure it's not going to get better than this conversation.
Speaker BSo I appreciate you taking the time and it's been very meaningful.
Speaker COh, well, I appreciate that.
Speaker CYeah, I had a lot of fun.
Speaker CIt's nice to be able to talk about this stuff on an intellectual level as well as a practical one.
Speaker AThanks again for being on.
Speaker AAnd remember, listeners, for all things BET, go to BET Ludwig.com and that's B E T T E L U d w I g.com and there'll be a link in the show notes.
Speaker AAll right, that's it for this time.
Speaker ASee you all next time.
Speaker AThank.
Speaker AYou.